Premier League's Worst Tackles: From Roy Keane to Mason Holgate

Introduction

Mason Holgate's recent foul on Brighton's Kaoru Mitoma has sparked widespread criticism and debate. While opinions differ on the role of VAR in the decision, there is little argument that the challenge was shocking. This incident raises the question: Was it the Premier League's worst ever tackle? In this article, we will explore five all-time horror tackles from the competition.

Roy Keane on Alf Inge Haaland

One of the most infamous tackles in Premier League history occurred in April 2001 during the Manchester derby. Roy Keane, representing Manchester United, clashed with Alf Inge Haaland from Manchester City. The animosity between the two players dated back to Haaland's time at Leeds. Keane's autobiography vividly describes the incident, where he launched a studs-first tackle on Haaland, followed by a display of triumph. Haaland, who is now the father of Erling Haaland, only played one more club game in his career. Keane initially received a three-match ban and a £5000 fine, but this was later increased to five games and £150,000 when his autobiography was published.

Conclusion

While Mason Holgate's recent foul has drawn significant criticism, it is important to remember that the Premier League has seen its fair share of horror tackles throughout its history. The incident involving Roy Keane and Alf Inge Haaland stands out as one of the most notorious examples. As fans, we can reflect on these incidents and engage in debates about the severity and impact of such tackles. Cast your vote for the worst tackle in the Premier League at the bottom and join the discussion in the comments section below.