Burnley Contemplates Legal Action Against Premier League Post-Everton Sanction

Burnley FC is reportedly assessing the possibility of initiating legal proceedings against the Premier League following the resolution of Everton FC's penalty for violating profit and sustainability regulations. In the 2021/22 season, Burnley was relegated from the Premier League, ending the season four points adrift of Everton. Subsequently, Everton was penalized with a six-point deduction—reduced from an initial ten—after surpassing the allowed £105 million loss limit by recording losses of £124.5 million over three years.

Discussions around seeking compensation from Everton were previously entertained by Burnley, alongside Leeds United and Leicester City, on the grounds of Everton's financial breaches during the seasons which saw the former club relegated. However, with Everton facing financial difficulties, Burnley's attention has now turned towards the Premier League. Allegations have been made suggesting the league's delayed action in penalizing Everton influenced Burnley’s relegation outcomes. The club is currently seeking legal counsel on potential financial claims against the Premier League for this delayed response.

The sanction, if applied during the 2021/22 season, would have seen Burnley remain in the Premier League, thus avoiding relegation. The potential for compensation was affirmed by David Phillips KC, the chair of the independent commission overseeing Everton’s case, who stated clubs could seek damages if a guilty verdict was confirmed.

Everton’s breach extends from the 2019/20 to the 2021/22 seasons, highlighting a period where Premier League's efforts to expedite the hearing were thwarted by delays agreed with by the independent commission. Further cases of potential breaches of the Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) involving Everton and Nottingham Forest are still under review.

As part of efforts to prevent similar delays in the future, Premier League clubs, during their 2023 annual general meeting, agreed to amend the rules. The changes mandate quicker submissions of club accounts and ensure independent hearings are concluded within a 12-week window post-complaint.

Burnley, now at risk of facing another relegation, is at a critical juncture. The team is positioned 19th, lagging 11 points behind safety, with just 11 games remaining in the league. Vincent Kompany, the team's manager, expressed his focus remains solely on Burnley’s immediate challenges, sidestepping queries related to Everton’s financial dispute.

This issue not only underlines the financial intricacies within the Premier League but also emphasizes the delicate balance of competition integrity and fairness. As Burnley weighs the prospects of legal action, the implications for football governance and club accountability remain in the spotlight.

For more updates on this developing story, join our new WhatsApp community to receive daily insights from Mirror Football, along with special promotions from our partners. Visit our Privacy Notice for more information.